ClinAds

Two dental chains. Each hides what the other shows.

Can AI tell you who the dentist is and what a cleaning costs? Aspen answers the first. Western answers the second. Neither answers both.

Watch the walkthrough, or open it on YouTube.

A patient types good dentist near me, how much is a cleaning. Two dental chains want that visit: Aspen Dental, with more than 1,100 offices, and Western Dental, with 227 across the West.

We read 78 Aspen office pages picked at random and all 227 Western Dental office pages, the way most AI crawlers read them: the raw page, before JavaScript runs. Aspen shows the dentists and the stars, but hides its offices from its own sitemap. Western shows the prices, but never says who the dentist is.

Search for a good dentist near me and the price of a cleaning: an Aspen Dental office page names Dr. Cecily Williams and shows a 4-star rating from 1,240 reviews but no price; a Western Dental office page shows a new-patient offer and Medi-Cal but no dentist and no reviews
Two dental chains. Each hides what the other shows.

Five questions: Aspen answers four, Western three. Never the same ones.

We scored the page a patient actually lands on, read before JavaScript runs.

Aspen Dental aspendental.com

4/5

  • ✓Where is it?
  • ✓Is it open now?
  • ✕What does it cost?
  • ✓Who is the dentist?
  • ✓What do patients say?

Western Dental westerndental.com

3/5

  • ✓Where is it?
  • ✓Is it open now?
  • ✓What does it cost?
  • ✕Who is the dentist?
  • ✕What do patients say?

Method: checked on November 18, 2026. Aspen Dental, 78 office pages reached from a seeded random sample of 80 of its 1,001 city pages; Western Dental, every office page in its sitemap. All read in Chrome before JavaScript. We also tried Tend, but its site blocked our browser outright.

Aspen tells a machine who the dentists are and what patients think

Every Aspen office page carries a business listing with a star rating, opening hours and a map pin, plus six questions answered for that exact town.

Aspen Dental Smyrna, TN · page data

"@type": "MedicalBusiness", "name": "Aspen Dental - Smyrna, TN",
"streetAddress": "440 Sam Ridley Pkwy W Ste 140", "telephone": "(615) 768-3242",
"aggregateRating": { "ratingValue": "4", "reviewCount": "1240" },
"FAQPage": "Is Aspen Dental accepting new patients?" …
77 / 78office pages with a star rating and town-specific FAQs a machine can read
76 / 78office pages that name their dentists, like “Dr. Cecily Williams”
An Aspen Dental office page carries a MedicalBusiness listing with address, phone, a 4-star aggregate rating from 1,240 reviews and town-specific FAQs
The dentists and the stars, in the data.

Then Aspen’s map for crawlers lists 134 pages. Not one of 1,100+ offices.

Ask aspendental.com for its robots.txt, sitemap or llms.txt and you get the same thing: a “Page Not Found” page, sent with an “everything is fine” status. A real sitemap exists at another address, but nothing points to it, and it only covers marketing pages.

0 / 1,100+offices in the sitemap. Crawlers can still reach them through the finder’s state and city links, but there is no direct list
1.1 MBmedian office page, with about 616 KB of script, to deliver 17,000 characters of text

Smaller gaps: the “Pricing & Offers” page shows no prices, and only 1 of 78 office pages mentions one. One sampled office link sends you to a different city, and one city page is titled “Find Dentists in [location]”.

Aspen Dental's robots.txt, sitemap and llms.txt all return a Page Not Found page with a 200 status, its real sitemap lists 134 marketing pages and no offices, and each office page weighs 1.1 MB
Great office pages, missing from the map.

Western’s pages are light, tidy and upfront about cost

Every Western Dental office page is marked up as a Dentist, with hours, a map pin and five FAQs. Each one states the new-patient offer and says Medi-Cal is accepted. Its robots.txt points crawlers straight to a working sitemap of every office.

Western Dental National City, CA · in the raw text

1539 East Plaza Boulevard, National City, CA 91950
Opening hours listed day by day · Medi-Cal dental accepted
“The regular price for these procedures in California is $378.”
143 KBmedian office page, about 8 times lighter than Aspen’s
227 / 227office pages with Dentist schema, hours, a price and insurance details
A Western Dental office page lists address, day-by-day hours, Medi-Cal acceptance and a $378 regular price in the raw text, and weighs 143 KB
Light pages that say what it costs.

227 offices. Not one review, not one dentist, almost no differences.

Every Western Dental office page has the same business name, “Western Dental”, the same five FAQs and no mention of who works there. Any two office pages share about 96% of their wording. To a machine, they read as one page copied 227 times.

Western Dental · same on every office page

"@type": "Dentist", "name": "Western Dental"
"aggregateRating": missing on 227 / 227
FAQ #1: “How can I afford dental care if I don’t have insurance?”
0 / 227office pages naming a dentist, and 0 that mention reviews at all
32 / 227sitemap links that redirect. Not updated since August, and the finder links 1 office before JavaScript

One odd line in robots.txt, “User-agent: AdsBot / Disallow: /”, blocks Google’s ad-checking crawler from the whole site.

All 227 Western Dental office pages share the name Western Dental, the same five FAQs and about 96% of their wording, with no reviews and no dentist named
One page, copied 227 times.

The scorecard: seven checks each, and they fail the opposite ones

Eleven checks, the same method, both chains.

CheckAspenWestern
Address and phone in readable textOn the raw page, before JavaScript✓✓
Opening hours in readable textNot only after the page loads✓✓
Business schema with map pin and hoursData a machine reads directly✓✓
Star ratings in the page dataaggregateRating on office pages✓✕
Dentists named on each office pageWho a patient will actually see✓✕
Town-specific FAQsQuestions that mention the location✓✕
Each office page reads differentlyUnder 80% of wording shared✓✕
Prices a crawler can quoteOn the office pages themselves✕✓
robots.txt points to a sitemapA real file, not a 404 page✕✓
Every office listed in the sitemapOne direct list for crawlers✕✓
Light office pagesUnder 300 KB of HTML✕✓
Scorecard of eleven checks: Aspen and Western each pass seven, Aspen on ratings, dentists and local detail, Western on prices, sitemap and page weight
Seven checks each. They fail the opposite ones.

Why this matters to a clinic

Aspen has thousands of reviews and named dentists, but makes crawlers hunt for its offices and never quotes a price. Western quotes prices and keeps its pages fast, but gives AI no reason to recommend one office over another: no reviews, no people, no local detail.

Each chain could fix its gaps in a few weeks. For a single clinic, the same checks take an afternoon, and most of the fixes are free.

  • We read your site the way an AI crawler does. Your pages, compared with the clinics near you.
  • You get the gaps in plain sentences. One list you can hand to whoever runs your website.
  • It takes a day. No commitment, no cost.

Source: AI crawler behaviour from Vercel, “The rise of the AI crawler” (December 2024).

View the full teardown slides (PDF, 8 pages)

Your browser can’t show the PDF here. Download it instead.

Download the slides (PDF, 249 KB)

Want a free AI visibility audit for your practice?

Free, and it takes about a day. We check your city and your competitors the way a patient does, then send back every gap in plain sentences.

Get my free audit
Keep reading

More research.